Is hydrogen or methanol better?

Hydrogen or methanol as a fuel for new energy vehicles: which is more competitive?

The main differences are as follows:

  • Methanol is a normal temperature liquid with lower storage, transportation, and filling costs; It’s much more expensive than hydrogen.
  •  The conversion rate of fuel cells is 40%-60%, and the comprehensive conversion rate of methanol extended range power generation is estimated to be 35%-40%, but fuel cells need precious metal foil gold as a catalyst, and the cost is not low. Now, Geely and other manufacturers are researching hydrogen fuel engines with a thermal efficiency of up to 40%+.
  • At present, hydrogen/methanol is mainly produced from fossil fuel exhaust, which is limited in terms of environmental protection and supply. In the future, it is certain to use the surplus energy of wind power generation to produce green hydrogen and then capture carbon dioxide through the atmosphere to produce green methanol, and the economy is about 40% higher than the existing architecture. Green hydrogen is the first product, the cost performance is higher than green alcohol; Green alcohol is now about 40% higher than the market price, and after large-scale industrialization, it is expected to soon be reduced to below the current price.

Hydrogen

High-pressure hydrogen in a family car has two fatal drawbacks.

One is explosion safety, and the other is the small space inside the car.

Explosion safety

In closed occasions such as tunnels and underground garages, the explosion concentration range after hydrogen leakage is very large, commercial vehicles can have fixed open parking lots, and family vehicles must park in underground garages. Even remember that there are hydrogen buses can not go through the tunnel, in addition, although the high-pressure hydrogen storage tank has multiple protection, but the high pressure is high pressure, there is still a probability of damage, at least the oil to gas car with much lower pressure also has the tank explosion.

Small space inside the car

The small space in the car is because the volume density of high-pressure hydrogen is too low, and a large volume of the hydrogen storage tank is needed to put hydrogen with a lifetime of 600 kilometers. So the space inside the car is compressed badly, you let the owner buy A B-class car, the space is not as good as the A-class car, the owner must be unhappy.

methanol

Methanol is an important candidate for hydrogen energy fuel, in addition to methanol cars +, methanol ships +, methanol power stations +(already used by 5G base stations), and so on. In addition to direct combustion in internal combustion engines, fuel cells can generate methanol (methanol reacts with water to produce hydrogen).

Methanol and gasoline characteristics are relatively similar, normal temperature and pressure liquid, no residue after use, in addition to the energy density is much lower and toxicity differences, as a gasoline flat is very good. The cost of changing gas stations to alcohol stations is not high.

Hydrogen storage can also have solid magnesium hydride + and liquid organic solutions; hydrogen storage density is very high. However, both of these are carrier types, and the volume changes little after hydrogen release, and they need to be recovered and re-hydrogenated to be used, with slightly more restrictions.

In the current market development, methanol may be more competitive, but with the subsequent development of hydrogen, whether it can surpass methanol is still unknown.

Update cookies preferences
WhatsApp

Get a Quick Quote!

x

    Get a Quick Quote!

    x